Legends
- Bobby Charlton
- Denis Law
- Lou Macari
- Arthur Albiston
- Denis Irwin
- Dwight Yorker
- Jesper Blomqvist
- Ronny Johnsen
- Quinton Fortune
- Luis Saha
- Wes Brown
- Bryan Robson
- Peter Schmeichel
- Nemanja Vidić
Season 1990s
- 1990-92 Bryan Robson
- Su Maozhen
- 1992-94 Paul Parker
- Denis Irwin
- Steve Bruce
- Paul Ince
- Mark Hughes
- Ryan Giggs
- Bryan Robson
- 1994-96 Alex Ferguson
- Phil Neville
- Paul Parker
- Andrei Kanchelskis
- Ryan Giggs
- Simon Davies
- David May
- David Beckham
- 1996-98 Jordi Cruyff
- 1998-00 Gary Neville
- Denis Irwin
- Jaap Stam
- Nicky Butt
- Andy Cole
- Ryan Giggs
- Wes Brown
- Quinton Fortune
- Henning Berg
- Michael Clegg
Season 2000s
- 2000-02 Juan Sebastián Verón
- Phil Neville
- 2002-03 Alex Ferguson
- Carlos Queiroz
- Fabian Barthez
- Gary Neville
- Phil Neville
- Juan Sebastián Verón
- David Beckham
- Nicky Butt
- Ruud van Nistelrooy
- Ryan Giggs
- David May
- Luke Chadwick
- Roy Keane
- Paul Scholes
- Michael Stewart
- Ole Gunnar Solskjær
- Diego Forlán
- John O'Shea
- Wes Brown
- Quinton Fortune
- Danny Pugh
- Mikaël Silvestre
- Bojan Djordjic
- Paul Tierney
- 2003-04 Wes Brown
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- Ruud van Nistelrooy
- Ryan Giggs
- Kléberson
- Eric Djemba-Djemba
- Darren Fletcher
- John O'Shea
- Mikaël Silvestre
- Mark Lynch
- Luke Steele
- 2004-05 Alex Ferguson
- Tim Howard
- Gary Neville
- Phil Neville
- Gabriel Heinze
- Rio Ferdinand
- Wes Brown
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- Wayne Rooney
- Louis Saha
- Ruud van Nistelrooy
- Ryan Giggs
- Roy Carroll
- Roy Keane
- Liam Miller
- Paul Scholes
- Eric Djemba-Djemba
- Ole Gunnar Solskjær
- John O'Shea
- Kieran Richardson
- Quinton Fortune
- Mikaël Silvestre
- Phil Bardsley
- Jonathan Spector
- Luke Steele
- David Jones
- Chris Eagles
- Paul McShane
- 2005-06 Alex Ferguson
- Carlos Queiroz
- Tim Howard
- Gary Neville
- Gabriel Heinze
- Rio Ferdinand
- Wes Brown
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- Wayne Rooney
- Louis Saha
- Ruud van Nistelrooy
- Ryan Giggs
- Park Ji-sung
- Alan Smith
- Roy Keane
- Liam Miller
- Paul Scholes
- Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
- Edwin van der Sar
- John O'Shea
- Kieran Richardson
- Darren Fletcher
- Phil Bardsley
- Mikaël Silvestre
- Gerard Piqué
- Giuseppe Rossi
- 2006-07 Edwin van der Sar
- Gary Neville
- Patrice Evra
- Gabriel Heinze
- Wes Brown
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- Wayern Rooney
- Ryan Giggs
- Park Ji-Sung
- Alan Smith
- Nemanja Vidić
- Michael Carrick
- Henrik Larsson
- Paul Scholes
- Ole Gunnar Solskjær
- Dong Fangzhuo
- Darren Fletcher
- David Jones
- Mikaël Silvestre
- Tomasz Kuszczak
- Chris Eagles
- Ritchie Jones
- Danny Simpson
- Tom Heaton
- 2007-09 Edwin van der Sar
- Gary Neville
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- Wayne Rooney
- Luis Nani
- Paul Scholes
- John O'shea
- Federico Macheda
- Danny Welback
- Rodrigo Possebon
- Fábio da Silva
- Rafael da Silva
- 2009-10 Mike Phelan
- Edwin van der Sar
- Gary Neville
- Patrice Evra
- Rio Ferdinand
- Wes Brown
- Micharl Owen
- Anderson
- Dimitar Berbatov
- Wayne Rooney
- Ryan Giggs
- Ben Foster
- Park Ji-Sung
- Zoran Tošić
- Nemanja Vidić
- Michael Carrick
- Luis Nani
- Paul Scholes
- Fábio da Silva
- Rafael da Silva
- Jonny Evans
- Darren Fletcher
- Antonio Valencia
- Gabriel Obertan
- Kiko Macheda
- Darren Gibson
- Tomaz Kuszczak
- Ritchie De Laet
- Craig Cathcart
Season 2010s
- 2010-11 Patrice Evra
- Nemanja Vidić
- Paul Scholes
- Darren Fletcher
- 2011-12 Mike Phelan
- David de Gea
- Patrice Evra
- Phil Jones
- Rio Ferdinand
- Jonny Evans
- Michael Owen
- Anderson
- Dimitar Berbatov
- Wayern Rooney
- Ryan Giggs
- Chris Smalling
- Park Ji-Sung
- Javier Hernández
- Nemanja Vidić
- Michael Carrick
- Luis Nani
- Ashley Young
- Danny Welbeck
- Fabio da Silva
- Tom Cleverly
- Darren Fletcher
- Antonio Valencia
- Fedrico Macheda
- Anders Lindegaard
- Ben Amos
- 2012-13 David de Gea
- Rafael da Silva
- Patrice Evra
- Phil Jones
- Rio Ferdinand
- Jonny Evans
- Antonio Valencia
- Anderson
- Wayne Rooney
- Ryan Giggs
- Anders Lindegaard
- Chris Smalling
- Javier Hernández
- Nemanja Vidić
- Michael Carrick
- Luis Nani
- Ashley Young
- Danny Welback
- Robin van Persie
- Paul Scholes
- Tom Cleverley
- Darren Fletcher
- Nick Powell
- Shinji Kagawa
- Federico Macheda
- Alexander Büttner
- Scott Wooton
- Bebe
- Sam Johnstone
- 2013-14 David Moyes
- David de Gea
- Rafael da Silva
- Patrick Evra
- Phil Jones
- Rio Ferdinand
- Anderson
- Antonio Valencia
- Wayne Rooney
- Ryan Giggs
- Michael Carrick
- Luis Nani
- Ashley Young
- Danny Welback
- Robin van Persie
- Fabio da Silva
- Tom Cleverley
- Darren Fletcher
- Shinji Kagawa
- Marouane Fallaini
- Anders Lindegaard
- Adnan Januzaj
- 2014-15 Louis van Gaal
- Louis van Gaal
- David de Gea
- Luke Shaw
- Phil Jones
- Marcos Rojo
- Juan Mata
- Ángel Di María
- Radamel Falcao
- Wayne Rooney
- Adnan Januzaj
- Chris Smalling
- Michael Carrick
- Delay Blind
- Ashley Young
- Robin van Persie
- Anders Hererra
- Antonio Valencia
- Paddy McNair
- James Wilson
- 2015-16 Louis van Gaal
- Albert Stuivenberg
- Frans Hoek
- Phil Jones
- Memphis Depay
- Juan Mata
- Anthony Martial
- Wayne Rooney
- Adnan Januzaj
- Chris Smalling
- Michael Carrick
- Daley Blind
- Ashley Young
- James Wilson
- Anders Herrera
- Antonio Valencia
- Marouane Fallaine
- Morgan Schneiderlin
- Jesse Lingard
- Bastian Schweinsteiger
- Paddy McNair
- Sam Johnstone
- Andreas Pereira
- 2016-17 José Mourinho
- Carlos Lalin
- Silvino Louro
- Ricardo Formosinho
- Emilio Alvarez
- Rui Faria
- David de Gea
- Phil Jones
- Paul Pogba
- Juan Mata
- Zlatan Ibrahimović
- Anthony Martial
- Wayne Rooney
- Chris Smalling
- Michael Carrick
- Daley Blind
- Marcus Rashford
- Ander Herrera
- Luke Shaw
- Antonio Valencia
- Marouane Fellaini
- Henrikh Mkhitaryan
- 2017-18José Mourinho
- David de Gea
- Victor Lindelöf
- Eric Bailly
- Marcos Rojo
- Juan Mata
- Romelu Lukaku
- Anthony Martial
- Chris Smalling
- Jesse Lingard
- Michael Carrick
- Ander Herrera
- James Wilson
- Nemanja Matić
- Scott McTominay
- Sergio Romero
- 2018-19Alex Ferguson
- Ole Gunnar Solskjær
- Phil Jones
- Paul Pogba
- Alexis Sánchez
- Markus Rashford
- Diogo Dalot
- Lee Grant
- Fred
- Andreas Pereira
- Ashley Young
- Sergio Romero
- Luke Shaw
- Antonio Valencia
- Marouane Fellaini
- Matteo Darmian
- 2019-20Ole Gunnar Solskjær
- Nicky Butt
- Mike Phelan
- Diogo Dalot
- Tahith Chong
- Juan Mata
- Jesse Lingard
- Andreas Pereira
- Daniel James
- Bruno Fernandes
- Lee Grant
Season 2020s
- 2020-21Markus Rushford
- Mason Greenwood
- Alex Telles
- 2021-22Ole Gunnar Solskjær
- Darren Fletcher
- Ralf Langnick
- 7 Cristiano Ronaldo
- 8 Juan Mata
- 9 Anthony Martial
- 11 Mason Greenwood
- 18 Bruno Fernandes
- 34 Donny van der Beek
- 2022-235 Harry Maguire
- 6 Lisandro Martínez
- 7 Cristiano Ronaldo
- 8 Bruno Fernandes
- 9 Anthony Martial
- 10 Markus Rushford
- 17 Fred
- 12 Tyrell Malacia
- 21 Anthony
- 18 Casemiro
- 20 Diogo Dalot
- 22 Tom Heaton
- 23 Luke Shaw
- 25 Jadon Sancho
- 29 Aaron Wan-Bissaka
- 34 Donny van der Beek
- 46 Hannibal Mejbri
- 49 Alejandro Garnacho
- 2022-23Eric Ten Hag
- Mitchell van der Gaag
- Steve McClaren
- 2 Victor Lindelöf
- 4 Phil Jones
- 5 Harry Maguire
- 6 Lisandro Martínez
- 8 Bruno Fernandes
- 9 Anthony Martial
- 10 Markus Rushford
- 12 Tyrell Malacia
- 14 Christian Eriksen
- 15 Marcel Sabitzer
- 17 Fred
- 18 Casemiro
- 19 Raphaël Varane
- 20 Diogo Dalot
- 22 Tom Heaton
- 23 Luke Shaw
- 25 Jadon Sancho
- 27 Wout Weghorst
- 28 Facundo Pellistri
- 29 Aaron Wan-Bissaka
- 31 Jack Butland
- 33 Brandon Williams
- 34 Donny van der Beek
- 36 Anthony Elanga
- 38 Axel Tuanzebe
- 39 Scott McTominay
- 49 Alejandro Garnacho
- 2023-24Mitchell van der Gaag
- Benni McCarthy
- Richard Hartis
- Darren Fletcher
- 1 Altay Bayindir
- 2 Victor Lindelöf
- 4 Sofyan Amrabat
- 5 Harry Maguire
- 6 Lisandro Martínez
- 7 Mason Mount
- 8 Bruno Fernandez
- 9 Anthony Martial
- 10 Markus Rushford
- 11 Rasmus Højlund
- 12 Tyrell Malacia
- 14 Christian Eriksen
- 15 Sergio Reguilón
- 16 Amad Diallo
- 17 Alejandro Garnacho
- 18 Casemiro
- 19 Raphaël Varane
- 20 Diago Dalot
- 21 Anthony
- 22 Tom Heaton
- 23 Luke Shaw
- 24 Andre Onana
- 28 Facuno Pellisteri
- 29 Aaron Wan-Bissaka
- 35 Jonny Evans
- 37 Kobbie Mainoo
- 39 Scott McTominay
- 46 Hannibal Mejbri
- 47 Shola Shoretire
- 2024-25Eric Ten Hag
- Rene Hake
- Darren Fletcher
- Jelle ten Rouwelaar
- Craig Mawson
- 1 Altay Bayındır
- 2 Victor Lindelöf
- 3 Noussair Mazraoui
- 4 Matthijs de Ligt
- 6 Lisandro Martínez
- 7 Mason Mount
- 8 Bruno Fernandes
- 9 Rasmus Højlund
- 10 Marcus Rashford
- 11 Joshua Zirkzee
- 12 Tyrell Malacia
- 14 Christian Eriksen
- 15 Leny Yoro
- 16 Amad Diallo
- 17 Alejandro Garnacho
- 18 Casemiro
- 20 Diogo Dalot
- 21 Antony
- 22 Tom Heaton
- 23 Luke Shaw
- 24 André Onana
- 25 Manuel Ugarte
- 35 Jonny Evans
- 37 Kobbie Mainoo
- 43 Toby Collyer
- 6 Hannah Blundell
- 13 Simi Awujo
- 21 Millie Turner
- 2025-26Ruben Amorim
- 1 Altay Bayındır
- 2 Diogo Dalot
- 3 Noussair Mazraoui
- 4 Matthijs de Ligt
- 5 Harry Maguire
- 6 Lisandro Martínez
- 7 Mason Mount
- 8 Bruno Fernandes
- 10 Matheus Cunha
- 11 Joshua Zirkzee
- 13 Patrick Dorgu
- 16 Amad Diallo
- 18 Casemiro
- 19 Bryan Mbeumo
- 22 Tom Heaton
- 23 Luke Shaw
- 25 Manuel Ugarte
- 30 Benjamin Šeško
- 33 Tyler Fredricson
- 35 Diego León
- 37 Kobbie Mainoo